.

  . ....
InIdaho.com » McCall » Lodging » Shore Lodge
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
Shore Lodge Reviews:
.
The Shore Lodge has an average overall review of 4.43 out of 5.00 by 167 InIdaho.com Users

[Viewable Results: 164] < Previous Reviews | More SHORE LODGE Reviews >

.
Donald Glenbrook, NV    2/15/2006   Survey ID: 17980

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: Wonderful experience. I highly recommend the facility. Truly first class!
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Donald's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Paul Boise, ID    2/15/2006   Survey ID: 18035

Overall Ranking

4 out of 5

4  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Non LakeView Suite
Comments: The room was nice, however, I think it should have come with a refridgerator seperate from the bar. Also, the staff didn't seem to be to informed about different events and activities during Winter Carnival time. I had to find most of the info out on my own.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Paul's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Jason Boise, ID    2/1/2006   Survey ID: 17594

Overall Ranking

3 out of 5

3  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: We could not eat in the restuarant, needed reservations, you figure if you spend $300.00 they could work you in somehow. there was no room service because they were understaffed. but the place was really nice, and romantic.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Jason's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
David Rineyville, KY    1/18/2006   Survey ID: 17333

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: The hotel is excellent and the staff is very helpful. There are lots of amenities and the restaurant is good, but could be great. The waitresses, although courteous and friendly, could use some more training in waiting in an establishment that costs as much as this does. Overall, an excellent choice and I will certainly be back sometime.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View David's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Keri Boise, ID    12/20/2005   Survey ID: 16825

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Comments: None.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Keri's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Chuck and Alvia Boise, ID    11/23/2005   Survey ID: 16596

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: None.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Chuck and Alvia's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
William Naperville, IL    10/12/2005   Survey ID: 16346

Overall Ranking

2 out of 5

2  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: This was my first visit to the Shore Lodge since it was remodeled under new management. The Whitetail is charging prices that are consistent with an "upper class establishment". The accomodations probably come close to meeting that expectation but we (my wife and I) found the food in the restrauntant to be subpar for the price charged (not that it was bad) and the service in the Bar area was horrific. We sat in the bar for over 30 minutes and no waiter service approached us (they were not busy). Finally I went out to the main desk and asked the desk clerk how to get someone to wait on us. She did appologize and called a waitress in the restaurant to come to the bar and serve us: she came once. We found the service in the bar unacceptable. When you add up not the subpar service end of our stay: we don't think the Whitetail has adequate value for what they charge.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
2 out of 3
out of three
1 out of 3
out of three

View William's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Susan Rancho Santa Fe, CA    10/1/2005   Survey ID: 16286

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: We loved the Lodge. The view was incredible and the service was very good. They have done a wonderful job with this lodge.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Susan's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Kimberly Santa Rosa, CA    9/27/2005   Survey ID: 16199

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Comments: The lodge and setting were beautiful. Will definitely stay there again.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Kimberly's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Carl  Buckeye, AZ    9/16/2005   Survey ID: 16086

Overall Ranking

4 out of 5

4  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: Very relaxing getaway. Recommend it for the outdoor sports.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Carl 's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Gay Little Rock, AR    8/17/2005   Survey ID: 15358

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Comments: The lodge and facilities were wonderful. We thought the lodge to be one of the most nicely decorated of any on our trio. The golf was wonderful and almost empty. The staff was somewhat inexperienced, but neverless. very helpful! We enjoyed our stay...
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Gay's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Scott Sandy, UT    8/17/2005   Survey ID: 15463

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: McCall was awesome. Would liked to have stayed there a lot longer. Georgeous place on earth.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Scott's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
James Boise, ID    7/20/2005   Survey ID: 14374

Overall Ranking

4 out of 5

4  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: A beautiful rooom and view of the lake with impeccable service.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View James's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Brian Longmont, CO    7/1/2005   Survey ID: 13911

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: It was an amazing experience. Wonderful place, beautifully decorated, incredible service. I could get used to it. Every night, when you went out for dinner, they would come and turn down your bed, a plate of warm chocolate chip cookies and a carton of ice cold milk, along with a weather report for the next day so you could plan. The restuarants food and service was incredible. Truly, one of the best places I've ever stayed.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Brian's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Kristin San Francisco, CA    2/22/2005   Survey ID: 12319

Overall Ranking

4 out of 5

4  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  
Comments: I went to the Whitetail Lodge with my parents for my mother's 60th Birthday. Debbie at the front desk went out of her way to put champagne on ice and a hand written card in the room. The rooms are beautiful and we loved having easy access to the hot tub. The continental breakfast was the only weak point.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Kristin's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Jeff Dos Palos, CA    2/7/2005   Survey ID: 11967

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  
Comments: Great place, safe for kids, nice people! Things to do! Very good food and cool place to stay.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Jeff's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Stephen Mountain Home AFB, ID    8/16/2004   Survey ID: 9599

Overall Ranking

4 out of 5

4  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  King Lake View Suite
Comments: The lodge, property, and amenities are fantastic and well worth the visit. But the dining room has a strict dress code. Nice beach, boat/jet ski docks, pool, hot tubs, and ambiance. InIdaho Ed. Note: See special note on main Whitetail page about the dress code.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Stephen's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Cindy Meridian, Idaho    8/13/2004   Survey ID: 9319

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  Standard King Non LakeView Room
Comments: The Whitetail Lodge was both cozy and extravagent. Except for the wedding reception, we felt like the only ones there. It is a perfect romantic getaway. The service was good, but there was not much of it, i.e. no bell hop to help with luggage, no waitstaff coming by the pool, etc. We were basically on our own. My husband searched the entire lodge looking for a drink to have on the dock. Besides that, we loved it!
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Cindy's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
James Reno, NV    8/11/2004   Survey ID: 9349

Overall Ranking

5 out of 5

5  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  Standard King Non LakeView Room
Comments: " No Disappointments "
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
2 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View James's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.
.
Andrea New York, NY    8/10/2004   Survey ID: 9330

Overall Ranking

4 out of 5

4  out of 5

out of 5
 
Shore Lodge product reviewed:  Standard King Non LakeView Room
Comments: The only concern was the limited amount of service (ie. hotel employees). There was noone by the pool, etc ... But the setting and lodge are spectacular.
 
Good Value Met Expectations Do Again
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three
3 out of 3
out of three

View Andrea's review of InIdaho.com's service

 
.
.

< Previous Reviews | More SHORE LODGE Reviews
[Results: 164]  PreviousPage 7 of 9  | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

siok

 

How do I review a product?  In November of 2002, InIdaho.com began sending an email to our guests within one week of their trip with the opportunity to review the product they booked and to let InIdaho.com know how they did.  If you have provided us with an email address we will send you a review for you to fill out right after you complete your trip.

Some reviews may be edited for content.  We try to display all reviews.  Poor reviews without a comment to explain the problem may not be visible online, but totals are counted in the overall ranking. 

Disclaimer: Reviews are our customers opinions and do not necessarily reflect InIdaho's opinion of a property.  Amenities, pricing, quality, or features mentioned in reviews are subject to change. 

This review page has been looked at by 72336 people.


Home | Lodging | Activities | Packages & Deals | Contact Us About InIdaho | Terms of Use  Privacy Policy

InIdaho.com is here for you!
Call us at 208-634-4787
Reservations: 1-800-84-IDAHO (1-800-844-3246)

Our customers are our best marketing campaign.  If you enjoyed our service, please tell a friend too.  Thanks.

InIdaho is a local, independent company, dedicated to great customer service and superior travel planning within the state of Idaho.

Travel Insurance is available to all our customers.  Click here to learn more about Travel Insurance.
Please Note:
 
We make every effort to keep this web site up-to-date and accurate.  Occasionally, suppliers may change their rates or policies and therefore, all rates and policies are subject to change without notice until reservation is confirmed. 

©1997-2024 InIdaho.com, LLC. The InIdaho.com logo and the "Sunflake"  symbol are trademarks of InIdaho.